I don't like or dislike it.

Yeah, I was a bit disappointed too..I really really like the crunchy chocolate chip cookies but I believe they are discontinued....oh well, I guess I just HAVE to try a new cookie now

I'm not crazy about it either. I thought it was just "meh". I wasn't in love with the old ones but I did like them better than this.

I think it's one of the most disgusting things I've ever eaten. I tasted like there was fruit in it instead of chocolate. YUCK!!!

That is fun. I love the cookie. I warm it up of about 15 second and drink it with my milk serve from breakfast. I just wished it was a little bigger.

I didn't mind it. Heating it up made it taste better.

I just don't like cookies that are like a small piece of cookie shaped cake. That's not a cookie to me. If they're going to make a piece of cake at least make it look and taste like one. I understand that they wanted to make it chewy but they could have done it without making it like this. They managed not to screw up the brownie so why not get this right too? At least the old choc. chip cookies had the consistency of cookies. Although they had a weird coconut aftertaste, LOL.

I figure if we're eating so little to begin with the dessert should be a home run, you know? This one just leaves me feeling unsatisfied.

Call me odd, but I loved the new soft chocolate chip cookie!

I was surprised at how small the cookie was. Once I got past that, I was suprised at how bland it was. It was neither soft nor hard, and tasted just kind of stale. For 120 calories or so, I'd rather have the cheese curls or toffee bites or cinnamon twists. Or better yet, a 100-calorie pack of Keebler fudge-striped bites.

So far, I've not been that happy with any of the new food items except the tortellini soup. Am waiting to try the honey mustard pretzels but my center doesn't have them in yet.

I liked the cookie also...

i love the cookie!!

have you guys tried heating it up?!?

i don't like it unless i do!
the chocalate melts, and the cookie gets softer!!

it is sooooo satisfying!!

try heating it up before you give up on it!!

i hated the hard cookies.

I agree that warming it up helps. No, it isn't as big as I would like or as good.....but that stuff is what got me to JC in the first place! LOL

JC does have receipes on this site for oatmeal and choc chip cookies and they rock, trust me.

i love it so much!!!!!

I have to say you must be on Jenny Craig for quite a while to be able to say you LOVED that cookie

I will have to try heating it up. I ate one today, which was my second one ever. Just as it was the first time, the cookie let me down. I like the softness, but the taste is more than lacking. I'm glad that some people really like it though!

I think I may be odd too. I like it. Warming it up for 10 to 15 seconds in the microwave makes it better.

Today was my first day, so I have nothing to compare it to, but I thought it was good. It was sort of what i was expecting it to be.

Blehhhh, didn't care for these.

The soft cookie was ewww...I ate it from the package and then I thought microwaving it would help...however, nothing can help this poor little cookie...it's just simply ewww

I love this cookie!
as some people already said try heating the cookie!

I eat this cookie 2 or 3 times a week...

warm cookie + milk = a happy me!

I thought it was okay.... will definitely try heating mine up next time, as thats how I used to like my soft batch cookies when I was little, and this definitely reminded me of those!

Also definitely MUST have milk with it... it was pretty dry!

Thumbs down for the cookie. But the cinnamon twists are outstanding!

My consultant suggested heating it .. I did and I loved it .. Thumbs up here

Don't like it, won't get it again. In fact, it "didn't agree with me" <<ick>>. I, too, would rather the 100 cal. Keebler fudge striped cookies.

I'll have to try heating it up. I thought it was bland and did not taste like a chocolate chip cookie. I could make it into a dessert - heat it up and add some strawberries and ff cool whip with a dusting of cocoa powder.

the toffee bites are really good

I nuked it in the microwave for 10 seconds and it was very good. But so far the toffee bites are my favorite cookie. And you get lots of them!